H 383 - A group narrated to me from Abul Hasan Muhammad Ibn Ahmad Ibn Dawood and Abu Abdullah Husain Ibn Ali Ibn Husain Ibn Musa Ibn Babawayh, saying: From the mistakes of Muhammad Ibn Ali in the religion in the segment of testimonials is that he narrated from the Seventh Imam that he said: “When your faithful brother has a right over another man, and he denies this right, and your brother does not have witnesses against him, but one person and he is a reliable witness, you turn to the witness and ask him about his testimonial. When he testifies to you, you testify along with him to the judge according to his testimony, so the right of a Muslim man is not trespassed.” The word is from Ibn Babawayh. He said: “This is a lie he has made and we don’t know of any such narration.” In another occasion he says, “He has lied.”